|
|
| | Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious | |
| |
| Author | Message |
|---|
CarterHallJunkie

Number of posts: 158 Age: 50 Location: St. Louis Metro Tobacco: Carter Hall - most OTC brands Pipe: Aldo Velani Ocotogon, No name (made in England) briar, Missouri Meerschaum cobs Registration date: 2011-08-07
 | Subject: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Sat Aug 27, 2011 10:36 am | |
| Read a review on Pipe Smoking Magazine about this McClelland blend. http://pipesmagazine.com/blog/pipe-tobacco-reviews/three-oaks-syrian-pipe-tobacco-review/ Anyone smoking this? What's your take? I'm intrigued. |
|  | | KevinP

Number of posts: 128 Tobacco: Dunhilll My Mixture #965, Billy Bud Pipe: Caminetto, Jacono, Ascorti Registration date: 2011-01-18
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Sat Aug 27, 2011 3:57 pm | |
| Just bought some last week but haven't opened it yet. |
|  | | ruta2
Number of posts: 108 Registration date: 2010-11-25
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Sat Aug 27, 2011 7:55 pm | |
| I've been smoking this blend for quite a while now and I have to say I'm a fan. I think you'll enjoy it if you like English/Orientals. |
|  | | PipePuffer

Number of posts: 203 Location: San Francisco Tobacco: Virginias, VaPers Pipe: English billiards Registration date: 2010-11-21
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:40 am | |
| I like this blend. Mellow and balanced indeed. |
|  | | raf66

Number of posts: 197 Age: 47 Location: Columbus, Ohio Tobacco: Hal O' The Wynd, Bob's Chocolate Flake, Irish Flake, Orlik's Golden Sliced
Pipe: Ascorti Peppino Billiard, Ser Jacopo Rowlette Candle Carving Tapered Billiard, Don Carlos Sandblast Lovat
Registration date: 2010-03-12
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:45 am | |
| Been wanting to try some of this blend as well. Let us know how you like it. |
|  | | Schmitzbitz
Number of posts: 78 Age: 32 Location: Port Coquitlam, British Columbia Tobacco: Three Oaks Syrian, Ten Russians, Tudor Castle Pipe: Uncle Arthur Spool, Iwan Ries Blasted Dog, GBD Prodigy or anything Brigham. Registration date: 2011-03-23
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Mon Aug 29, 2011 10:38 am | |
| I may be biased, but this blend has rapidly catapulted itself to the forefront of my rotation, to the tune of about a tin per week. Very tasty stuff! I am curious about the Three Oaks Original, particularly after reading Ted Gage's response to the review. |
|  | | Mr_Houston

Number of posts: 80 Location: Houston, TX Registration date: 2008-01-28
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Tue Aug 30, 2011 5:55 am | |
| Absolutely the best I've found in quite some time. My review:
Simply stated, I love this blend. When I moved from cigars to pipes in 2001, my first enjoyable english blend was Ashton Celebrated Sovereign - and it had Syrian latakia. Upon further research , my holy grail tobacco became Pease Rennaisance, which was already becoming hard to find. I cellared as much as I could reasonably afford. I've been on a Syrian latakia quest ever since. Many of the blends have been good, but the McClelland's offerings have had so little of the Syrian, that I've been dissapointed. Until I got to try 3 Oaks Syrian.
The best thing about this balanced blend was that is had enough of the fabled Syrian that I could really enjoy it. Since its release by McClelland, I've stocked up sufficiently.
This is a very well-balanced blend. It is classic English, with the use of great quality Syrian. When first smoked it, I realized that is was the very same Syrian used in Pease's Rennaissance. It was obvious. The orientals and virginias are classic English quantities. Just wonderful.
I will say that the blend has a slight harsh quality to it upon first light that mellows thoughout the bowl. I believe that is will subside with age. I've cellared enough to see if I am right.
That said, I get bored smoking the same blend all the time. I need a change of pace now and again. Upon the recent release of several new Syrian blends by McClellands, I sought that occassional compliment to 3OS. The test blends were Samovar, Ringlow Syrian Reserve, Celebrated Sovereign, and Wilderness. I liked them all, but have determined that my change-of-pace blend will be Samavor. I took them all to my pipe club meeting, and the majority preferred Wilderness.
Now I am comfortable that I can smoke the rest of my Rennaissance, while my 3OS ages. Then, I will still be content with great quality Syrian latakia blends, as I age as well.
|
|  | | CarterHallJunkie

Number of posts: 158 Age: 50 Location: St. Louis Metro Tobacco: Carter Hall - most OTC brands Pipe: Aldo Velani Ocotogon, No name (made in England) briar, Missouri Meerschaum cobs Registration date: 2011-08-07
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Tue Aug 30, 2011 8:02 pm | |
| | Mr_Houston wrote: | | Absolutely the best I've found in quite some time. |
I have a 50g tin on order - from this review (thank you for the well thought out, detailed review) it sounds like I may be cellaring some of this blend and letting it age.
Love the insight of my Brothers here. Thank you. |
|  | | choch

Number of posts: 13 Age: 47 Location: Cincinnati, Ohio USA Tobacco: Penzance, Dunhill 965 & Nightcap, McClalland 3 Oaks syrian & Blue Mountain, LJ Peretti Cambridge Flake, Balkan Sasieni, Pease Albington. Pipe: Vintage BBB's, GBD's, Stanwell, Bjarne, Knute, Ben Wade, Petersons, Chacom Deluxe, Barling, Aldo Velani, And a few others. Registration date: 2011-08-28
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Wed Sep 07, 2011 9:18 pm | |
| Hi Gents,
I found 3 Oaks Syrian at my local B&M, Strauss Tobacconists here in Cincinnati, today. I'm smoking it right now, and all I can say is WOW!! This is some very luscious and mellow latakia. I could smoke this stuff all day, and just might were it not for having to work. My TAD is going to get way out of control at this rate between 3 Oaks, Blue Mountain, Penzance, Cambridge Flake and various Dunhills. |
|  | | CarterHallJunkie

Number of posts: 158 Age: 50 Location: St. Louis Metro Tobacco: Carter Hall - most OTC brands Pipe: Aldo Velani Ocotogon, No name (made in England) briar, Missouri Meerschaum cobs Registration date: 2011-08-07
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Thu Sep 08, 2011 5:33 am | |
| | choch wrote: | Hi Gents,
I found 3 Oaks Syrian at my local B&M, Strauss Tobacconists here in Cincinnati, today. I'm smoking it right now, and all I can say is WOW!! This is some very luscious and mellow latakia. I could smoke this stuff all day, and just might were it not for having to work. My TAD is going to get way out of control at this rate between 3 Oaks, Blue Mountain, Penzance, Cambridge Flake and various Dunhills. |
Hey Craig - I've been hearing good things about Blue Mountain
Your thoughts? |
|  | | choch

Number of posts: 13 Age: 47 Location: Cincinnati, Ohio USA Tobacco: Penzance, Dunhill 965 & Nightcap, McClalland 3 Oaks syrian & Blue Mountain, LJ Peretti Cambridge Flake, Balkan Sasieni, Pease Albington. Pipe: Vintage BBB's, GBD's, Stanwell, Bjarne, Knute, Ben Wade, Petersons, Chacom Deluxe, Barling, Aldo Velani, And a few others. Registration date: 2011-08-28
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Thu Sep 08, 2011 3:11 pm | |
| I just got a tin of it delivered, so I'll let you know in a couple of hours! From all accounts it's excellent. I used to smoke Balkan Sobraine 759. it will be interesting to see how close they were able to come to it.
|
|  | | Dock BoB's Team

Number of posts: 2354 Age: 101 Location: @ The Gym Tobacco: Arturo Fuente "Hemingway" Pipe: Former Collector of High End Briar Registration date: 2007-12-15
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Thu Sep 08, 2011 4:42 pm | |
| I've been smoking this on an off for a month now. It's been a looooooooong time since I've tasted latakia but I'm really loving it. I will be very curious to see how this stuff mellows after a few years and I have a couple of tins set aside to find out... |
|  | | choch

Number of posts: 13 Age: 47 Location: Cincinnati, Ohio USA Tobacco: Penzance, Dunhill 965 & Nightcap, McClalland 3 Oaks syrian & Blue Mountain, LJ Peretti Cambridge Flake, Balkan Sasieni, Pease Albington. Pipe: Vintage BBB's, GBD's, Stanwell, Bjarne, Knute, Ben Wade, Petersons, Chacom Deluxe, Barling, Aldo Velani, And a few others. Registration date: 2011-08-28
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Thu Sep 08, 2011 7:17 pm | |
| Gents, I am smoking my first bowl of Blue Mountain right now, I received it in the mail just today from LJ Peretti (along with a sampler of their house Omega blend). I also smoked 3 Oaks Syrian for the first time just last night. The Blue Mountain is very good indeed, but I used to smoke 759 and to me Blue Mountain is not in the same ballpark. As I said, it's very good in it's own right, but it's a rather mellow and light bodied blend. The 3 Oaks Syrian is a richer and more full bodied blend IMHO. I want to try Black House next, but the 3 Oaks Syrian will be staying in my rotation while the Blue Mountain will not.
|
|  | | CarterHallJunkie

Number of posts: 158 Age: 50 Location: St. Louis Metro Tobacco: Carter Hall - most OTC brands Pipe: Aldo Velani Ocotogon, No name (made in England) briar, Missouri Meerschaum cobs Registration date: 2011-08-07
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Thu Sep 08, 2011 7:54 pm | |
| I know they are dissimilar blends, but along the "something new" front - I tried my first bowl of Rattray's Red Paparee (thanks again Frost) tonight and thoroughly enjoyed it. My mouth is still dancing with the sweet, spicy and completely enigmatic taste of this tobacco. I could get used to this! Anyone have any experience with this one they could share? |
|  | | Schmitzbitz
Number of posts: 78 Age: 32 Location: Port Coquitlam, British Columbia Tobacco: Three Oaks Syrian, Ten Russians, Tudor Castle Pipe: Uncle Arthur Spool, Iwan Ries Blasted Dog, GBD Prodigy or anything Brigham. Registration date: 2011-03-23
 | Subject: Re: Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious Fri Sep 09, 2011 9:57 am | |
| | choch wrote: | Gents, I am smoking my first bowl of Blue Mountain right now, I received it in the mail just today from LJ Peretti (along with a sampler of their house Omega blend). I also smoked 3 Oaks Syrian for the first time just last night. The Blue Mountain is very good indeed, but I used to smoke 759 and to me Blue Mountain is not in the same ballpark. As I said, it's very good in it's own right, but it's a rather mellow and light bodied blend. The 3 Oaks Syrian is a richer and more full bodied blend IMHO. I want to try Black House next, but the 3 Oaks Syrian will be staying in my rotation while the Blue Mountain will not.
|
I think you'll enjoy the Black House, its a very deep, rich blend with huge earthy notes of peppers, smoke and meat. I find that the flavour profile is surprisingly complex, with the Latakia and Orientals weaving a delicate balance that is very interesting...although I would have to put Black House closer to the savory end of the spectrum than 3OS, with its bold sweet notes. Two things about Black House have really stood out for me (outside of the flavour profile); the burning qualities of the leaf used are second to none - I find the blend burns almost as well as CH or PA, and secondly, the nicotine in the blend really sneaks up on you. It seems quite mild in the N deptartment, until you get into the last third of the bowl.
Adam Smith |
|  | | | | Three Oaks Syrian - Sounds Lucious | |
|
Similar topics |  |
|
| | Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |