What Are Your Top Ten Tobaccos?

[Volkditty]

This has been on my mind a lot over the last year as I've actively been seeking out new blends and trying to build a deep cellar of the ones I love.

My current top 10, in no particular order:

John Dengler - 1917
Peterson - Early Morning Pipe
Peterson - Old Dublin
Robert Lewis - Tree Mixture
GL Pease - Embarcadero
Mac Baren - Capstan Blue
Mac Baren - HH Old Dark Fired
Peter Stokkebye - Luxury Twist Flake
Escudo - Navy de Luxe
John Aylesbury - General 1776

 

[Timbo]

I think all mine are still in production, I won't tease by putting unobtaniums in there.

In no particular order...

Arango Balkan Supreme
HH Latakia Flake
HH Old Dark Fired Flake.
GLP Chelsea Morning
Aged Escudo, fresh never lives up to its fruity aroma for me.
GLP Westminster
GLP Quiet Nights
SPC Plum Pudding, Special Reserve if you can get it.
Presbyterian Melange
Balkan Sasieni

 

[mosin1932]

Love seeing these old threads stoked back to life! I'm just going to put what I have smoked/stocked the most of, in order (otherwise I would drive myself crazy lol)

1. Half n' Half
2. Peterson Sherlock Holmes
3. Stokkebye Luxury Navy flake
4. Sutliff 507c Virginia slices
5. Sutliff Bright Burley & Virginia (sps-22)
6. Ennerdale flake
7. Orlik Golden slices
8. Erinmore flake
9. Bosun plug/cut-plug
10. SPC Plum Pudding

 

[Idlefellow]

Most of my all-time favorites are gone. Here's most of what's on hand presently...

McClelland's British Woods (old stock still on hand)
Edward G. Robinson's
Half & Half
Sir Walter Raleigh
Carter Hall
Country Squire's Figgy Pudding
Orlik Golden Sliced
Presbyterian
Rattray's Black Mallory (the reissue)
Old Dark Fired

 

[bergencabin]

So far? (I'm only a month in so I can only do a top 3 haha)

Peterson's Early Morning Pipe (wow, what a gentle and nice little English)
Cornell and Diehl's Rajah's Court (such a fun and interesting smoke! Love the orientals)
Capstan Blue (which is surprising because I don't love straight Virginia's at all... this is just massively good)

Thought I would like, but don't -
Orlik Golden Sliced
All aromatics... (I bought so many... why???)
HH Old Dark Fired (I like this OK, but I don't like the cigar flavors)

 

[mosin1932]

Most of my all-time favorites are gone. Here's most of what's on hand presently...

McClelland's British Woods (old stock still on hand)
Edward G. Robinson's
Half & Half
Sir Walter Raleigh
Carter Hall
Country Squire's Figgy Pudding
Orlik Golden Sliced
Presbyterian
Rattray's Black Mallory (the reissue)
Old Dark Fired

I keep seeing people talking about figgy pudding lol, it must not be available until closer to christmas. How does it compare to their other aros? "White rose" is the only CS tobacco that has stood out to me so far.

 

[D.L.Ruth]

I keep seeing people talking about figgy pudding lol, it must not be available until closer to christmas. How does it compare to their other aros? "White rose" is the only CS tobacco that has stood out to me so far.

Yea only available around Christmas time and it usually goes pretty quick.