A bit late but I'm going to toss in my top 5.
5. Kinky Friedman Big Richard: It's been a while since I've had one of these, but that's because I can't find them in the shops I go to. Great cigar, and out of the 3-4 Kinky Friedman cigars I've tried it's been the best of the bunch with nice coffee/chocolate notes.
4. LFD Double Ligero Digger: One of the bigger sticks I've smoked. Can't say I remember anything standing out about it outside of just being a good smoke, and I don't think that's a bad thing. Definitely worse ways to spend a couple hours, few better if you're outside with a good drink.
3. Tatuaje Gran Cojonu: Great, big stick. Love corojo wrapped cigars and this was no exception. ( Honorable mention: Punch Rare Corojo which is a smaller, less expensive corojo cigar I love. Notes of dried fruit, really turned me onto corojo wrappers)
2. LFD Cameroon Cabinet Lancero: Mild, long and delicious smoke. I kept getting notes of vanilla which really tickled my fancy since I love vanilla. First lancero I've ever tried and I believe what I've read, that the lancero vitola allows a more focused smoke on the wrapper since there's less tobacco to "dilute" the taste, so to say.
1. My Father 2010 Limited Edition: I'm not sure about the other My Father cigars, but I know this one had pelo de oro tobacco and it was just different from anything else I've smoked. I don't know if that difference came from that tobacco included in this cigar but I have to say that I'd love to see more cigars that use pelo de oro tobacco.
Great thread, it definitely is a reference for cigars to try.
