Here's what I know.
I approached Mark about making us a POY, gave him my idea for the shape, told him we wanted it to be like the other club pipes he does where Mark puts up a few examples on his website under Club Pipes and anyone who wants one orders one directly from his website. This way we do not have to presell a bunch of pipes, wait a long time for a carver to make X number of pipes and ship them all at once, or try to collect a bunch of money at once and deal with that headache. I asked him for the two versions, the coral and the black and tan shown in this thread. You can look at his website (amsmoke.com) and see what a coral goes for and what a B&T goes for (the B&T can vary in price) and get a ballpark idea of what the pipes will cost. We just got through the stage where he has made the two prototypes shown in this thread, there was a delay because he had trouble sourcing a large enough, correct colored acrylic, which turned out to not happen. No matter, as the buffalo horn looks really cool. I accepted his prototypes as of this morning, and I asked him about price and availability. Waiting for that response.
Phew!
If you should want him to make a smooth or some special variation, I have no problem with it, that would be between the two of you. I went with the two versions shown because 1) they look great, and 2) they are an excellent value for the money and fit with most guys' request for a nice but affordable pipe. It's unique, it'll have a BOB Club stamp, it'll look good and his pipes are notoriously good smokers.