I recently acquired a beautifully colored WDC Meerschaum Straight Bulldog with what I believe is a genuine Amber diamond shanked stem and an ornately decorated metal (possibly Brass) stem band. The Amber stem is badly chewed at the button, but the entire pipe is intact, including the screw tenon (black plastic, not bone). It does draw air, but the draw is a bit tight. A pipe cleaner passes through from button to draft hole. It came with its original WDC fitted leather case with it's original gold foil WDC label, badly worn but still fairly legible.
I believe that this pipe would date back to the early 20th Century, sometime between 1900 and the 1930's. What I'd like to know is whether or not I should consider getting the Amber stem repaired to remove the tooth chatter left from the countless years spent enjoying this classic vintage pipe long enough to color the nearly pristine bowl and diamond shank so deeply. If I have the stem sanded and polished to remove all that chatter, will the value of this pipe be lost or greatly devalued? I don't intend to smoke this pipe very often. But I would like to smoke it looking a bit cleaner at the stem end. Am I violating the history and character of this vintage beauty by removing years, possibly decades, of what it took to achieve this depth of patina?
I believe that this pipe would date back to the early 20th Century, sometime between 1900 and the 1930's. What I'd like to know is whether or not I should consider getting the Amber stem repaired to remove the tooth chatter left from the countless years spent enjoying this classic vintage pipe long enough to color the nearly pristine bowl and diamond shank so deeply. If I have the stem sanded and polished to remove all that chatter, will the value of this pipe be lost or greatly devalued? I don't intend to smoke this pipe very often. But I would like to smoke it looking a bit cleaner at the stem end. Am I violating the history and character of this vintage beauty by removing years, possibly decades, of what it took to achieve this depth of patina?