191 is pretty popular, and P&W/Carole are fantastic. I very naturally started steering away from aromatics because I don't have much of a sweet tooth, but I personally found 191 to be a bit flat. On the other hand, some of P&W's other aros might be worth your trying. Put together a sampler pack by calling Carole, she won't mind a bit. 8)
Maple Cavendish is another well thought of aro from Carole..I enjoy it myself, though I've found a maple or two I prefer.
I also enjoy her Rum Kake, and a few others aros she offers which I can recommend are Gramercy Park, Gotham Court, Bleeker Street, and Bohemian Mixture.
When I ordered my 2 oz. sample 191 from P & W, Carole included a small pack of Bleeker St. Both are good. I usually shop for samples on the internet, and found a couple aromatics from milantobacco.com. I am partial to Doctor's Orders and Sportsman, but try samples from all over. You will find one that satisfies your tastes.